What Influences the News Coverage that Candidates Receive on Issues?
A look at Education Coverage in the 2004 Presidential Election

Appendix

Introduction | Background | Expectations | Data | Results | Conclusions | Appendix

Table 1. Dependent Education Variables

Variable

Mean

Standard Deviation

Minimum

Maximum

All coverage

6.454

5.826

0

52

Individual Candidate coverage

Clark

.243

.500

0

2

Dean

.595

.974

0

5

Edwards

.432

.771

0

3

Gephardt

.151

.453

0

3

Kerry

.492

.984

0

5

Lieberman

.103

.322

0

2

Table 2. Frequency Distribution of Dependent Variable Capturing all Coverage Concerning Education

Stories published

Frequency

Percent

0

8

4.32

1

9

4.86

2

16

8.65

3

29

15.68

4

21

11.35

5

22

11.89

6

19

10.27

7

12

6.49

8

6

3.24

9

2

1.08

10

7

3.78

11

4

2.16

12

5

2.70

13

8

4.32

14

3

1.62

15

2

1.08

16

3

1.62

17

2

1.08

19

1

0.54

20

2

1.08

21

1

0.54

22

2

1.08

52

1

0.54


Table 3. Frequency Distribution of Dependent Variables Capturing Coverage of Candidate and Education

Variable

Frequency

Percent

Clark

   

0 articles

146

78.92

1

33

17.84

2

6

3.24

     

Dean

   

0 articles

117

63.24

1

42

22.70

2

15

8.11

3

8

4.32

4

1

0.54

5

2

1.08

     

Edwards

   

0 articles

131

70.81

1

34

18.38

2

14

7.57

3

6

3.24

     

Gephardt

   

0 articles

162

87.57

1

20

10.81

2

1

0.54

3

2

1.08

     

Kerry

   

0 articles

135

72.97

1

26

14.05

2

14

7.57

3

4

2.16

4

5

2.70

5

1

0.54

     

Lieberman

   

0 articles

167

90.27

1

17

9.19

2

1

0.54


Table 4. Independent Education Variables

Variable

Mean

Standard Deviation

Minimum

Maximum

Press releases

       

Clark

.075

.337

0

3

Dean

.086

.282

0

1

Edwards

.162

.437

0

2

Gephardt

.043

.229

0

2

Kerry

.124

.347

0

2

Lieberman

.038

.218

0

2

All

.530

.897

0

6

Number of candidates in race

5.398

1.253

1

6

Days of the week

       

Monday

.146

.354

0

1

Tuesday

.146

.354

0

1

Wednesday

.146

.354

0

1

Thursday

.141

.348

0

1

Friday

.141

.348

0

1

Saturday

.141

.348

0

1

Debate

.086

.282

0

1

State of the Union Address

       

Day before

.005

.074

0

1

Day of

.005

.074

0

1

Day after

.005

.074

0

1

Time

       

Days from beginning

93.5

53.838

1

186

Days until South Carolina primary

65.351

50.175

0

155

Days after South Carolina primary

2.5

6.695

0

30


Table 5. Frequency Distribution of Independent Variables

Variable

Frequency

Percent

Press releases

   

Clark

   

0

174

94.05

1

9

4.86

2

1

.54

3

1

.54

Dean

   

0

169

91.35

1

16

8.65

Edwards

   

0

160

86.49

1

20

10.81

2

5

2.70

Gephardt

   

0

178

96.22

1

6

3.24

2

1

.54

Kerry

   

0

163

88.11

1

21

11.35

2

1

.54

Lieberman

   

0

179

96.76

1

5

2.70

2

1

.54

Number of candidates

   

1

1

.54

2

14

7.53

3

7

3.76

4

8

4.30

5

14

7.53

6

142

76.34

     

Debate

   

Debate held

16

8.65

No debate held

169

91.35


Table 6. Regression Model of Candidate Coverage in the New York Times and Washington Post Concerning Education

Calculated while candidate contested race

(Standard Error)

 

Clark

Dean

Edwards

Gephardt

Kerry

Lieberman

Constant

2.20**

(.63)

-1.50

(.78)

.17

(.46)

.03

(.13)

.69

(.50)

1.85**

(.59)

Press releases issued by candidate concerning education

-.14

(.15)

.53*

(.24)

-.03

(.13)

-.04

(.15)

.31

(.17)

.19

(.10)

Number of real candidates in race

-.32**

(.10)

.17

(.12)

-.06

(.06)

 

-.20**

(.07)

-.30**

(.095)

Monday

.05

(.15)

.63*

(.26)

.37

(.20)

-.05

(.15)

.65**

(.23)

.04

(.09)

Tuesday

-.13

(.15)

.24

(.25)

.09

(.20)

.07

(.15)

.42

(.22)

.13

(.09)

Wednesday

-.23

(.15)

.38

(.26)

.23

(.20)

-.01

(.15)

.43

(.23)

.09

(.09)

Thursday

.16

(.15)

.53*

(.25)

.52**

(.20)

-.10

(.15)

.61**

(.22)

-.01

(.09)

Friday

-.03

(.15)

.18

(.25)

.04

(.20)

-.16

(.15)

.17

(.22)

-.01

(.09)

Saturday

-.09

(.15)

.17

(.26)

-.12

(.20)

-.07

(.15)

.06

(.22)

.04

(.09)

Debate

-.09

(.15)

.31

(.25)

-.05

(.20)

-.14

(.15)

.35

(.22)

-.02

(.09)

Day before State of the Union Address

-.29

(.52)

.61

(.90)

.18

(.73)

-.35

(.49)

-.86

(.81)

-.02

(.29)

Day of State of the Union Address

.30

(.68)

-1.54

(.92)

-.49

(.76)

.53

(.49)

-.64

(.81)

.89**

(.29)

Day after State of the Union Address

.67

(.52)

2.02*

(.89)

1.28

(.73)

 

3.15***

(.81)

.45

(.32)

Days from beginning

-.0004

(.001)

.01***

(.002)

.004**

(.001)

.003*

(.001)

.01**

(.001)

-.001

(.001)

R2

.14

.27

.23

.09

.41

 

* p<.05, ** p<.01, *** p<.001


Table 7. Regression Model of Candidate Coverage in the New York Times and Washington Post Concerning Education

Calculated during entire race

(Standard Error)

 

Clark

Dean

Edwards

Gephardt

Kerry

Lieberman

All candidates

Constant

.67

(.37)

-1.81**

(.58)

.17

(.46)

-.62*

(.29)

.69

(.50)

-.08

(.24)

9.81**

(2.90)

Press releases issued by candidate concerning education

-.14

(.15)

.53*

(.24)

-.03

(.13)

-.03

(.15)

.31

(.17)

.18

(.11)

.82

(.44)

Number of real candidates in race

-.23**

(.09)

.17

(.12)

-.06

(.06)

.10

(.06)

-.20**

(.07)

.03

(.06)

-1.02*

(.39)

Whether the candidate is in race

.99**

(.29)

.34

(.43)

 

.04

(.18)

 

-.08

(.19)

 

Monday

.03

(.14)

.58*

(.25)

.37

(.20)

-.07

(.13)

.65**

(.23)

.03

(.09)

9.75***

(1.29)

Tuesday

-.12

(.14)

.23

(.25)

.10

(.20)

.01

(.13)

.42

(.22)

.11

(.09

-.04

(1.26)

Wednesday

-.21

(.14)

.38

(.25)

.23

(.20)

-.03

(.13)

.43

(.23)

.06

(.09)

.36

(1.29)

Thursday

.18

(.14)

.57*

(.24)

.52**

(.20)

-.03

(.13)

.61**

(.22)

.07

(.09

1.47

(1.26)

Friday

-.04

(.14)

.28

(.25)

.04

(.20)

-.11

(.13)

.17

(.22)

.03

(.09)

6.36***

(1.27)

Saturday

-.06

(.14)

.15

(.25)

-.12

(.20)

-.07

(.13)

.06

(.22)

.03

(.09)

0

(1.27)

Debate

-.11

(.13)

.21

(.24)

-.05

(.20)

.01

(.12)

.35

(.22)

-.04

(.09

-.52

(1.23)

Day before State of the Union Address

-.31

(.50)

.67

(.91)

.18

(.73)

-.31

(.46)

-.86

(.81)

-.09

(.33

4.77

(4.63)

Day of State of the Union Address

.27

(.66)

-1.52

(.93)

-.49

(.76)

.62

(.46)

-.64

(.81)

.83*

(.33

-2.34

(5.14)

Day after State of the Union Address

.70

(.50)

2.02*

(.90)

1.28

(.73)

.79

(.47)

3.15***

(.81)

.73*

(.35)

7.53</